Kill City
Australian crime fiction is our M.O. The Kill City podcast is all about Australian crime writing, crime books and the Australian crime writing industry.
Tune in for author interviews, catch up on the latest industry news and book releases, and everything else happening in the Australian crime fiction scene.
Kill City
Amy Doak in the spotlight - Part One
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode, we speak to Amy Doak, who shares her journey from media and freelance writing to becoming a highly successful young adult crime author.
She discusses her writing process, character development, and how her Australian regional setting influences her stories. In this episode, Amy Doak shares insights into her writing process, the challenges of creating new voices, and her thoughts on the future of YA crime fiction. Discover how she overcomes writer's block, collaborates with her support crew, and engages with her diverse readership.
The books of Amy Doak
- Eleanor Jones is not a Murderer
- Eleanor Jones Can't Keep a Secret
- Eleanor Jones is Playing with Fire
- Eleanor Jones is not Drowning
- What have they done to Liza McLean
Booktopia Affiliate Program
The Kill City Podcast is a part of the Booktopia Affiliate Program, meaning that when you purchase a book from Booktopia using one of the above the links, we get a small commission. Or as they'd say in the crime world, a kick back!
At the Kill City Podcast we love celebrating and promoting the work of Australian writers, publishers and bookstores, and we hope you do too.
Disclaimer
The episode transcripts are auto-generated, and while all efforts are made to ensure their accuracy, there may be some instance of incorrect spelling and/or errors in the accuracy.
www.killcitypodcast.com.au
The Kill City podcast acknowledges the traditional custodians of the land we're on. Here in Melbourne, that's the Wurundjeri Woi Worong people of the Cullen Nation. We honour their deep connection to storytelling, a tradition carried across more than 2,000 generations. Pay our respects to elders past, present, and emerging, and we extend that acknowledgement to First Nations people listening today.
SpeakerWelcome back to Kill City, where Australian crime fiction is our MO. Today we're chatting with someone who's been on our radar for a while, and especially after Troy Hunter gave her a massive shout-out on the pod, the brilliant young adult crime author Amy Doak. Hi, Amy, great to have you here.
Speaker 1Hi Leigh and Helen, thank you for having me.
Speaker 2Hello, Amy. It's so good to meet you. Now, if it's all right with you, I'd like to kick things off by giving people a quick rundown of your backstory. So you're a self-confessed lifelong lover of books, reading, and writing. You started out of media, radio, TV, advertising. You founded the Bendigo magazine, I think back in about 2005. Then you moved into freelance writing, and somewhere along the way, YA crime grabbed you by the collar. So your debut, Eleanor Jones Is Not a Murderer, exploded onto the scene in 2023. And it was a David Award YA fiction winner, a CBCA notable, ABIA shortlist, and it even picked up the Singapore Red Dot Award for Older Teens. Then you've published Eleanor Jones Can't Keep a Secret. Eleanor Jones is Playing with Fire. And most recently, Eleanor Jones is not drowning. Plus, your standalone YA mystery novel, What Have They Done to Liza McLean, has just won the David for best YA novel. So huge congrats for all of those. So you live in Bendigo with your husband, two teenage kids, a dog, and a very grumpy cat. Now, and I have to say, we're sensing that this is becoming a bit of a pattern. Because we interviewed Fiona Hardy a couple of weeks ago, and she also has a grumpy cat. So Leigh and I don't own cats, but we're trying to work out whether this is an Australian crime writer thing or just a cat owner thing. So either way, it's a mystery that we're going to keep investigating, but any clues that you can give us would be very greatly appreciated. What is it about grumpy cats and authors?
Speaker 1I don't know, but I'm very impressed with your detective work. There's very few people that have gone digging so deep as to get the Bendigo magazine connection. And also the um Singapore Awards. So I I don't normally get people pick that up. So I'm impressed, Helen. You maybe you've got a bit of sleuthing in you as well. So thank you.
Speaker 2I just Google is my best friend. Yeah, I do, and I love going down research rabbit hole. So but the funniest thing about the Singapore Red Dot Awards is when I Googled it at first, it said it was for mature readers. And I'm like, hang on, she's a young adult fiction. And then I just worked out that their definition of mature readers is the mature section of young adult readers.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, yeah. And it's the same with the CBCA that they have older readers as the category, which probably would confuse people if they didn't know that it was for kids' books. So yeah.
Speaker 2The other thing that I almost want to do another separate podcast in is your other books that you've involved writing, and that one that you've got about the list making, that was just music to my ears, and I seriously want to put that on my Christmas list because I love making lists. It's beautiful. I will organise a copy for you, Helen.
Speaker 1It's for fun. I'm I'm a big believer in I have a lot of theories about the power of lists and um definitely the power of writing things down. I think there's a lot to be said for taking things out of your your brain and putting them on paper. Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, no, I agree. I think that's really good. Yeah, I think we're missing a bit. I still always have my notebook with me. I'm I'm a bit old school like that. So yeah, it's pretty cool.
SpeakerIt is funny, I spent half of my life trying to be more digital and the other half trying to be more analogue, but I always take notebooks with me everywhere I go. Let's wind back the clock a bit. You know, what we like as a kid. Sounds like you were a big reader early on. Firstly, what did you cut your teeth on in a writing sense? And what's the first thing you remember being properly proud of from a writing perspective?
Speaker 1I yeah, I was a really early reader, which I didn't realise was a unique thing until I got much older. I thought everybody, you know, that loved books just kind of I I don't remember a time when I wasn't reading. And when I was I moved around a lot when I was a kid because of my dad's work, and I actually went to three different primary schools in prep. And the first one that I went to, they gave me um this wonderful, it was like a trifold A4 folder that had these little strips and a whole lot of words that you could add words a bit like the poetry magnets that you can get for the fridge now. And so it was this idea that you could take all these little singular words and make stories out of them. And it was my most favourite thing to do, which makes me sound like such a little nerd from being a four-year-old that you know got a kick out of writing stories from this little folder that I would carry around everywhere with me and pester people to make stories with me. So that's one of my earliest memories of storytelling was having these these words and being able to shuffle them around to make stories. I thought was a really magical thing to do. And I remember in primary school too, which I think all kids do, um, they use computers now, but back in the day we had typewriters and and our own hand drawings, but make you know, you'd make your own book and you'd write it and illustrate it and then laminate the cover and you know staple it together and all that. And most of the kids in my class, I think was probably grade two when we did that, and everybody else did one of those, and I did about five of them. Um because I was so obsessed, and then I would at home it's all I wanted to do as well. So I think I've always just wanted to make things and make stories, and um, the whole process has been is so interesting to me from the the storytelling at the very beginning right the way through to something you can hold in your hand and and share. So I I just love it, and I've always I can't remember a time when I haven't loved it. Yeah.
SpeakerUm you had such a long stretch in the media and freelance writing as well, so radio, TV magazines. Um so when did it hit you that you wanted to move from non-fiction into fiction?
Speaker 1Uh I always did, but I was too scared to tell anyone. It was sort of the little secret dream that I always had, and I've always written, so even when I it was something I always wanted to do, but I I kind of lived and grew up in a space where creative things were a hobby, they weren't a job. So all of the jobs that I did when I I did marketing and computer programming at uni, which weird combination, but I needed to do something that was nearby where we lived. We couldn't afford to go away and and you know live on campus or anything like that, so that I had restrictions with my education. Um and so I chose subjects within my majors that would allow me to write. So everything I kind of did was writing adjacent. So when I was working in, you know, television, I wanted to work in in this script stuff, and I wanted to, I ended up writing TV commercials and and when I went it w went into advertising, I I'm writing press releases and and press ads and print ads and things like that. So everything that I did sort of became this how can I get a real job and uh and and somehow make it writing adjacent. And in amongst that, I was doing writing courses, and all through my 20s, I I did weekend courses on writing books and I did uh um editing and writing diploma at TAFE at night school and all sorts of things that I was constantly learning the craft and and doing all these sort of secret squirrelly, and everyone who was close to me knew that I loved writing, but I sort of didn't say it out loud, and it wasn't really until so my youngest is is nearly 15, and when he was about two and a half, there was a writers' festival in town, and I was able to get a little bit of time away from being a mum on a weekend and going to the writers' festival, and it was so amazing. I was like, he's my people, I've found this space, and I came home so inspired, and and that was kind of the kicker. I started to meet other people who also loved writing, and and then in about 2018, 2019, I had a really dear friend who um had cancer, and we had lots of conversations about regrets that you might have in life, and I have none. Um I don't really believe in regretting things because they always take you where you are right now, um, every decision that you make. And but the one thing I think I I said to her then that I would have regretted if something happened to me tomorrow was I never wrote that novel, I never finished it. I'd started so many, but I hadn't finished it. So I made a promise to myself that I was going to I had three really solid ideas of stories I wanted to write, and I said I was gonna I was gonna have a go at writing each of those three, so um that was the the goal I set myself. And the first one I wrote, and it was an adult action adventure thriller, and I um had such fun, and I had some wonderful writing friends who were real cheerleaders and really encouraged me. One of them was Katrine Nanisted, who writes amazing middle grade fiction and lives down the road from me, and she was my early reader, so she would say, I'm coming past your house, put some ch chapters in the letterbox, and I'll pick them up on the way past. And and she would then I'd get a text message from her later saying, That was amazing, what happens next? And it probably wasn't amazing, but she was able to push me and keep me going, keep me going. And so when I finished that, I was a bit hooked and addicted to the process. So I did pitch that book and I got some really lovely feedback from agents and publishers, but they all sort of agreed that they didn't know how they would sell it or where it would sit on the shelf because it it didn't really fit in a spot, and by that stage I'd started the second idea, which was a YA mystery, Eleanor Jones.
SpeakerSo, where was the point where you thought, actually, all right, I can I can do this and and really backed yourself in?
Speaker 1I know that when I was writing that I realised that one of the things I always did was I'd get to about 20,000 or 30,000 words in an idea and then really doubt myself. And I would think this is too hard, this is really boring, no one will want to read this, why am I wasting my time with this? And really kind of uh talk myself out of it. And a lot of the time I'd think, actually, I've got a better idea now, and maybe I'll just can this one and start my new shiny idea. Now that I have written as many books as I have from start to finish, as well as the five that are published, there's a few others in the can. And each time I get to about 20 or 30,000 words, and I say to people around me, this is terrible, this is so boring, everyone will hate this. And thankfully, I have some people who know me really well, and they'll say, Amy, check your word count. And I seem to be right on on track with that kind of 30,000 word mark that I just am no good at the middle, and it was the thing that always tricked me up because I'd get in my own way and I'd quit. And now I know I have to actually joke when I do school visits, it's a little bit like that book going on a bear hunt. Uh, you know, you can't go around it, can't go over it. Um, you will gotta go through it, and and so I just accept now that that's the hardest part of writing for me, and every other aspect of it I love. And if I can just get through that tricky middle, then the downhill run to the end is so much fun, and when I finish it, it's such a great feeling, and I just can't wait to get started on the next idea. So, yeah. Yeah, wow.
SpeakerSo being conscious of that now is that you are you changing your approach at all with the way you sort of push through the middle, or is it just acceptance where you just know it's gonna be hard and it's just a matter of yeah, yeah, and I I am.
Speaker 1I'm just I I joke with my writing, I've got a beautiful writing group, um, and we meet pretty regularly, and I'm such a whiny little cow when I'm halfway through something. And they're really patient with me. So it's that's that's nice. It's nice that I've got people who know me and know my process. And and actually, even my son said to me when I was I just had recently finished a project, and I I was saying to him, Oh, this is I don't know if this is any good, and he and he just rolled his eyes and said, No mum, you say that every time. So they they all know me too well now. Yeah.
Speaker 2Oh dear kids will just tell it to you how it is, won't they? There's no no sugar coating, which is which is a bit like Eleanor, I think. So I want to I want to jump into your first novel. So Eleanor Jones is not a murderer. So just for people who may not have read it, just to give a quick pricey. So Eleanor's actually on her ninth high school in under five years. She's just kind of keep trying to keep her head down. Um, and then the first kid that she talks to, Angus Marshall, um, actually gets stabbed the same day. But there's a text message from her sitting on his phone. So she starts digging and she falls in with this sort of motley little crew that kind of becomes her gang, and together they uncover Angus's secrets and there's the danger that's sitting right there in the middle of town. And I have to say, Eleanor Jones is just such a cracking main character name. So, how did you land on it and what came first, the name or the character herself?
Speaker 1Yeah, I out and out stole Eleanor Jones.
Speaker 2Um, you didn't.
Speaker 1Yeah, a friend of mine uh had a little girl, and many years ago, and when I got to meet Eleanor for the first time, I actually said and and actually Eleanor's older sister is Veronica, Veronica Jones, which is also an incredibly cool name. And Eleanor's mum is Jackie, Jacqueline Jones, also a very cool name. And so I joked that I would steal that name, and and one day I would write a story about Eleanor Jones because I said it was main character name, well and truly. And so um I would say it was probably seven years later that my niece at the time she was 15, and she was a bit of a reluctant reader and quite often complained about the sort of books that she wanted to read the kind of things she was watching on screen. So she had some favourite movies and some favourite TV shows, and she was saying to me, Why can't I find something that feels like this? I, you know, I want it to be fast-paced and I want to have some scary bits, but I also want it to be funny, and I want uh there to be friendship stories, but not at all about the drama. I want it to be about the mystery, and there were all these kind of elements, and I realised that's so much of what I love to read too, and so the combination, I suppose, of you know, my sarcastic 15-year-old niece who was in high school at the time, and and the name Eleanor Jones just seemed to fit together, and and then Eleanor became real almost overnight. Yeah.
Speaker 2And did she write herself? Like, did you have an idea about what the mystery would be fairly early on, or did you kind of have to flesh that out as you went?
Speaker 1Yeah, I think the initial scene in that book where it starts and she's on the bus going to school, and and that was the first thing that came. I I wrote that really early, and I actually wrote it in third person past tense because that was how I I was used to writing. That was my favourite way to write, I suppose. And it was Katrina who said to me, You know what? Yeah, this is a YA, I think you should try and write it first person, and and and I was like, Oh gosh, I don't know if I can do that. And then she said, and actually you should really write it present tense as well. And I thought, I definitely can't do that. But I sat down and I rewrote sort of the first six or so chapters in first person present, and while I was doing it, it really brought her to life, and and then it almost felt like I was cheating that someone was sitting next to me telling me a story because her voice became so real in that in that process, so yeah, best advice I ever was given, I think.
Speaker 2Yeah, no, that's really cool. And I think for me, um look, I've I absolutely loved it, and I have to admit I've raced through all four books, and I'm gonna have to watch myself about which which which book is which because I read them all so quickly. But I think for me it is that such an authentic voice that she has, and I I really love that the present tense first person and particularly her inner monologue that she has because it's just hilarious, and I just love a book where you can just laugh out loud because it doesn't happen that often with especially some of the books we read are a bit more serious and you know I'm different. So this this is like a breath of fresh air, and there's just one scene that just made me laugh out loud. And sorry, Leigh, I just snuck this bit in because I um I've I highlighted it in my notes on my Kindle. So she's she's stressing about getting on this really cool dude who we'll get to know very well called Ethan Griggs on his motorbike, who she doesn't know very well at this point. And she says something like, What if I die? Min will kill me, and I'm wearing my old undies that give me a wedge because they're too small and they're faded, and they have Pokemon on the ass cheek. No one needs to see them. Like I was just in stitches, laughing at death. And I think the other thing I like is that it kind of gets to the point of things that teenagers really worry about, but you kind of just help them make light of it. So, how do you get that voice so right? Is it you channeling your inner teenager or is it because you've got teenagers at home or um probably combination actually?
Speaker 1I I've been really fortunate to be surrounded by teenagers for quite a while now because of family and family friends, as well as my own kids and their friends, and because I worked freelance for a long time as well, prior to being published, I have always had pretty flexible work hours. I've you know, sometimes the kids would go to bed and I would work at night and things like that, and that meant that I was sort of the the mum that could do the things whenever all the other mums were working, and so I often did school pickup and or drop-off for kids, and I was the footy mum, which I'm not sporty at all, but I was the one that would corral kids from school to the football training and then do proof of life photos and send them off to the parents to make sure they knew that everybody had got there okay because they all used to walk to get there, and and so because of I mean you you get a bunch of kids in your car and they all tell you everything, and so that I realized pretty early on um being around teenagers that even though the world has changed a little bit, maybe it hasn't, and there's a lot more technology than there used to be, we're all still the same, and all the things that probably worried my grandma worried me and will worry my children and will worry their children, and there is a certain thing that about coming of age that doesn't ever change, and the stresses and the worries, and you you're sort of so into yourself at that age and you should be because you're trying to find yourself. Uh, and I think that that's something that you know I mean I know people who are well into their 30s who are still dealing with all of those things. So yeah, I I don't know, I think that yeah, it's it's a very familiar world, and it feels sometimes it feels like I was that age yesterday, you know, when when I'll hear them stressing about something or complaining about something, and I think, yeah, yeah, things is things are the same.
unknownYeah.
Speaker 1True.
SpeakerTeenage a recently become teenager, and yeah, it is uh I find myself not eavesdropping, but yeah, when you're right, when they're in the car with their friends and you're sort of listening to what they're talking about. Like it's it's an interesting trip down memory lane. Before we jump into the book too, I do want to say I loved Eleanor Jones is not a murderer as well, and and all the books. Um she is such a sharp and funny and real teenager. She's got a bit of that Miss Marple, and I love her mystery solving skills are quite elite, and and Helen's commentary on her voice is spot on. Um I actually had the pleasure of both reading a hard copy and listening to the audio book, as I sometimes do just to keep up with my reading load. Uh and it was a really fun listen as an audiobook. Lola Bond, I think, the uh the narrator. So we spoke to Fiona Hardy about this a couple of weeks ago because I think the the uh the narrator that's done her two books was wonderful as well. But what was that whole experience like of choosing a narrator and or listening to the various auditions for lack of a better one?
Speaker 1Well, I probably I mean, this was my first book, so I probably didn't get the luxury that some authors do of you know having a stable of voices and having a lot of say in all of that. Where I was really fortunate though, the the incredible young woman who's in charge of the production of my audiobooks, Veronica Ease, with Penguin Random House, is just such a gun at what she does, and she really seems to understand the material that she gets. And so when she first read Eleanor, she sent me a message and we chatted about the kind of voice that we wanted and what what she thought as well as what I thought, which is pretty much the same thing. And then she came back to me with Lola's Lola's tape and said, I think I've I've found you know Eleanor. And my only worry initially was that that Lola was a little bit well spoken. I wanted Eleanor to be a bit more of a bogan. Um she's a kid who'd moved around a lot, and she was a country kid, and and I wanted that to be reflected with her voice, and uh, and so that was my only sort of production note, and I think Lola absolutely nailed it. She's she's such a star, and with each book, I think she gets better and better, and and really has embraced the character of Alinor so much. And actually, there's a there's a show on stand called F Ward uh about uh nurses and doctors in a hospital, and Lola is one of the stars of that show. Um gorgeous little redhead, and she is just an absolute yeah, so talented and so generous with what she does. And uh, I I couldn't be luckier to both have Veronica and Lola, you know, doing that. I trust them so much with it, so it's great.
SpeakerAlright, so if we talk, Eleanor Jones can't keep a secret. Throw Eleanor straight back into trouble after um everything that happens in the first book. A private message leaks, uh, a secret spreads through Coinda, and suddenly she's back in the thick of another mystery. When did you realise Eleanor needed a second book? And what were the key things you wanted to carry forward from the first one?
Speaker 1So when I received the offer for the first book, I was really fortunate that I signed with an agent around the same time as I had pitched a Penguin, and so it all kind of happened at the same time. And so, because of that, my agent was amazing and managed to score me a two-book deal rather than a single contract. So I had originally, and I had mentioned it in my pitch, that I had four ideas in my head of four stories for Eleanor, and I didn't think for a moment that would ever happen because it's you know, series are hard and you know you have to often wait for a long time to see if something is taking off before you get a commitment on something else. And so I had done a little blurb on the second book though of Eleanor Jones Can't Keep a Secret, and I was very excited about the idea and and I was really fortunate that uh everyone agreed to it, and so I knew really early on that I was able to at least do two. And I I get quite frustrated if you read books in a series and and the big chunk of the the second book or the third book is recapping previous books, and so I wanted it to be something that someone knew could completely dive in, and it didn't matter if they hadn't read the first one or not, but also that they would be quite rewarded with a few in-jokes and a few little you know side stories if they had read the first one, and I continued to do that through each consecutive book as well. Uh, and the other thing that I was conscious of was not leaving anything on a cliffhanger, so that each book, if it happened to be the last book in the series, that was okay too. Uh, and it was you you felt quite satisfied that Eleanor was in a good place at the end of each book, and so they were sort of the two things that I I really focused on just in case, but also sort of secretly crossing my fingers that I was going to get a little bit more. So the second one though, I was able to write that comp in completion before the first one came out, and that was a really exciting time because to know that I was under contract and that someone wanted it, uh, but also not have anyone have an opinion yet about my work. So I could write it in this really great space where I was feeling amazing about where I was at, but I also had no judgment and no one looking over my shoulder, and no one, you know, other than the deadline of getting it in, no one really waiting for anything. So it was a really sweet spot to be in to write that second book. Yeah.
SpeakerYes, very cool, very cool. And your characters, Eleanor's crew, so Troy, Elfie, Angus, Namita, Ethan, they just feel like real kids, you know, like not sort of cliched cartoon teen type characters. And again, you know, they gave me again gave me such a great sense of nostalgia for my teenage years, uh, as long ago as they were. And the dialogue is bang on. So is much coming from your own memory on this, or is it again having teenagers around and having so many teenagers in your orbit kind of thing?
Speaker 1Yeah, I think the thing that a lot of people like I try really hard not to use any slang in in any of the books. It youth slang, the risk of sounding like an old person, it dates so quickly, and sometimes you could, you know, potentially use a word that all the kids seem to be using, and then six months later it's like no one says that. What are you doing?
Speaker 2Yeah, six seven, no one says six seven anymore. Yeah, that's it.
Speaker 1Very firmly, very firmly the other day. I was conscious of that, but the other thing that I've noticed about younger like kids and teens is that often the majority of them speak no differently than the adults in their world speak, and they're all much more eloquent than they get given credit for. Um, and often you'll have one kid in a group who uses all the slang and thinks they're hilarious, and they kind of do it just to wind up the adults around them, but the rest of them just speak like everybody else speaks, and so you know, I and I I I think the other thing is too, I I never wanted to to write down to them. I find teenagers to be so insightful and thoughtful and intelligent, and I I wanted to respect that, and so I often get adults who'll read my books and and be say in surprise, oh I really enjoyed that. I don't know what they were expecting out of a YA book the way that that kids speak and uh the things that they talk about and how passionate they are about the world and all of those things. Um, you know, there's not a lot of difference between speaking with someone who's 15 or 16 versus speaking to someone who's 25 or 26 or 35 or 36. Uh that what they're talking about might be different, but we're we're we're more similar than we are different, I would be. Yeah.
SpeakerInteresting. So and the main adults in Eleanor's life. So Min, I find Min quite fascinating. Um and she's so well written, and I love that she is not what you would stereotypically consider to be like a normal adult, you know. I could probably use better, oh sorry, a normal a normal parent type person, you know, and I and but that is the reality in in life. I think it's probably just not reflected all the time in uh in books and certainly in in TV and those sorts of things. So I re so I really enjoyed that dynamic between the two of them, and then of course obviously there's the Sergeant Holly Williams as well, and she's a sort of sharp no-nonsense type. How did you build these two characters and sort of what went into making them you know both as authentic as they are?
Speaker 1Yeah, I I think we all know someone who the child is more mature than the parent. Everyone has a friend like that, and I definitely know a few people like that, and that you know, you've got a a parent or parents even who um have a lot of fun and do a lot of things, and sometimes it's the kid that's making sure that you know everything's happening at home that needs to happen, or that their their school uniforms washed or you know the groceries are done or anything like that, and it doesn't necessarily mean that it's a bad parent or a parent that's neglectful. And I wanted to sort of show that that a lot of adults don't have their act together and doesn't mean that they don't love their kids any less, it just means that not everyone knows what they're doing, and so that that's kind of where Min's at, that she's really responsible in a lot of ways, and in other ways she just drops the ball, you know, um, big time, and that also benefits me as a storyteller because it means that Eleanor's not got someone looking over her shoulder every time she wants to go off and you know find a murderer. So that's handy as well. But um, and also Holly, uh I definitely wanted to have that a voice of reason, I suppose, from an adult space that can come in and um but someone who's young enough still to understand teenagers and and relate to them on that level. And so I have a a a good friend who's a police officer and and her name is Holly, and she gets along great with my kids and their friends, and and so you know, and she's the person actually that I would, you know, text in the middle of the night and with no point of reference whatsoever and ask a really random question about would someone be arrested for this or how would it work if this happened, and she doesn't even ask anymore, she just answers the question, so it's really helpful. Um she's great. I've got a friend that's a nurse that does that for me too. Yeah, so I I think it's that it's stealing from from a little bit from here and there and everywhere of of people around me and how they interact with their children and those relationships that that parents and kids have when kids get to a certain age and it's different for every family. And I suppose that each of my characters has a little bit of a combination of all of those things that I see around me. Yeah.
SpeakerUm, thank you. Your explanation of Min and the family dynamic is was far more articulate than my question was. So thank you for saving me there, Amy. I appreciate that.
Speaker 2Oh, you're too harsh on yourself, Leigh. Yeah, I reckon. Alrighty, I would like to talk now about the third book. So this one is Eleanor Jones is playing with fire. And in this one, we find that um Eleanor is as always trying to keep her head down. But when her neighbour dies in a suspicious house fire and more fires start popping up around the town, she's still pulled straight back into the mystery. And then a note arrives, an anonymous note, telling her to be quiet, and then she's basically just far deeper in than she ever meant to be. So one of the other things I really like about your books is they're very grounded in kind of regional Australia, you know, regional Victoria. They feel really Australian. But in my research, they often get compared to like the really big international YA mystery writers, like so Holly Jackson series, Karen McManus. So how where do you feel that your um books sit alongside these? Do you kind of we talked about sort of different age brackets, but I think there's some sort of talk about whether some are sort of more considered more cozy or a bit more wishy. How do you kind of frame and what what do you think yours, where where do they fit?
Speaker 1Yeah, I don't know. It's when you when you pitch an idea to publishers, they're often looking for some sort of comparison with what else is out there in the market, just so they know where it fits and and the kind of reader who would be interested in that sort of thing. And so there was definitely, you know, leveraging off the success of Karen McManus and and Holly Jackson was sort of a no-brainer there, even though if you really sort of got down to it, it would uh they're quite different in and just as they're quite different to one another as well. Yes. Um, and Jennifer Lynn Barnes is another another author that often gets uh talked about a lot that's a YA author, but her a lot of her stuff is sort of more puzzle-based, she uh maybe is slightly younger than Hermit Manis. I could there's all these different nuances that you can find in amongst those different authors. I'm I just feel really grateful to be put in the same category as any of them because they're all really successful and that's wonderful. If I could have a little tiny piece of that, I'll take it for sure. But um yeah, I think that when I first pitched Eleanor to you know publishers and agents, I I said uh a modern day Nancy Drew meets the dry was what I talked about. That it was just to indicate that it was a teen sleuth, um, but also that it had that Aussie Rule noir kind of vibe to it as well. Uh but then when I started thinking about it, I'm actually no, it's probably more Trixie Belden than Nancy Drew because there's a group of friends and it's maybe not as you know, Nancy Nancy was a bit of a snob with her convertible car and her wealth.
Speaker 2Yeah, she was quite kind. I did like her back in the day, but looking back at her now, I'm a bit like, ooh, yeah.
Speaker 1So, you know, there's definitely similarities but differences in all of those comparisons. And I would say, you know, there are moments in all of my books that are get a bit tense and a little bit scary, and everyone seems to really enjoy that, but you kind of always know that Eleanor's going to be okay, which gives you that sort of sense of safety reading it. And I think the other thing is I tend to write lean towards cozy more in that I don't go into anything too gruesome, so there's not descriptions of bodies and things like that, that all happens off the page. I I do think that often your imagination is enough, and there's certain scenes, it's not really a spoiler in the second book when Eleanor and Troy have to hide, and there's a skeleton that they're sharing a small space with, and there's a few jokes that are cracked in amongst that. But I've had people say to me, Oh, that was so scary, and I was so terrified. And and so I think sometimes the idea of something can be scarier than the actual description of things. But because I do leave a lot of that off the page and allude to things without going into too much detail, it means that it's opened up a really broad age range. So I've got readers as young as 11 or 12, right through to I had a book club of women in their 60s and 70s that had read the second Eleanor and and you know loved it, which was great. So that's fantastic for me, you know, that it that it hits the mark with so many people. Yeah.
SpeakerIt's almost like you've forecast my next question because I was going to ask. So I'm really curious about this, and yeah, so what you think the appropriate the entry age is for an Eleanor series. So you think it's about 11 and 11 or 12?
Speaker 1Yeah, I feel like any anything you get some really good readers in grade five and six, and they read it no problem, but also when I talk to them, sometimes there's a lot of the teenage stuff that goes straight over their head. And so, in a way, they're sort of missing out. And I talk when I talk to kids at schools, and I especially with good readers or advanced readers, because I was one of them. What tends to happen, and it really frustrates me, is that they get encouraged to read up. So, you know, a a 12-year-old boy, for example, who is a strong reader and has, you know, raced through Percy Jackson and you know Harry Potter and all those books, then suddenly gets adult fiction shoved in his hand rather than because old YA is too easy. And that I first I find it a little bit offensive, I'm not gonna lie. Um, because just because it's a a lesser word count shouldn't make for anything as far as the storytelling goes. But the thing is, YA is specifically written for that audience because it's issues that they should be able to relate to and characters that they can relate to that are their age, just the same as middle grade is for 10, 11, 12, you know, up to 13, 14-year-olds, depending on the story. And it's not so much about ability as it is about comprehension and and the place that you're at. And so, even though, yeah, younger readers can read Eleanor, they might enjoy it, they're not going to get as much out of it as when I talk to, you know, 13, 14, 15-year-olds, which is a sweet spot MYA, and the things that they relate to and the issues that they want to talk to me about that are beyond the mystery, um, means that I've I've kind of done it right in my mind. So, yeah, I would say anyone can read Eleanor if they're you know, if they're reading at that level, they're short, they're the short chapters, it's easy to read. Uh, it's a really accessible language, but if you want to get the most out of it, it kind of helps if you've if you've been through that age group or you're you're heading into those dynamics with friends and relationships and all that sort of thing as well, because you'll just enjoy it more because you get it. Yeah.
SpeakerSo I asked that question, my good friends uh Tim and Emma, and I know Tim will be listening, and their daughter Millie, I gave her the si or we gave her the series uh for her 12th birthday. Um so yeah, I was curious to know where where you thought the the entry entry was.
Speaker 1So um I always say to people, like no, if your 10-year-old reads it, they're not gonna be traumatized, it's okay.
SpeakerSo Helen, did I did I cut one of your questions out, Helen? Did I jump right over the top of you? I did. I just saw a little bit of an opening there to get to the It's okay.
Speaker 2You you go you go to the next one, all good. Sorry.
SpeakerApologies. Well, that's the end of part one of our conversation with Amy Doak. Be sure to join us next week for part two.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
In Competition
Sean & Jim
He Read She Read
He Read She Read
Writer's Routine
Dan Simpson
Stories Behind the Story with Better Reading
Better Reading PodcastLiterary Anything
City of Marion Libraries
Talking Aussie Books
Claudine Tinellis