Kill City
Australian crime fiction is our M.O. The Kill City podcast is all about Australian crime writing, crime books and the Australian crime writing industry.
Tune in for author interviews, catch up on the latest industry news and book releases, and everything else happening in the Australian crime fiction scene.
Kill City
Hayley Scrivenor in the spotlight - Part Two
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In part two of our conversation with Hayley Scrivenor we get a teaser for her next novel, and it is fascinating!
We talk Girl Falling and Hayley tackles our quick and the curious round and passes with flying colours... totally as expected!
Find Hayley's books on Booktopia
Booktopia Affiliate Program
The Kill City Podcast is a part of the Booktopia Affiliate Program, meaning that when you purchase a book from Booktopia using one of the above the links, we get a small commission. Or as they'd say in the crime world, a kick back!
At the Kill City Podcast we love celebrating and promoting the work of Australian writers, publishers and bookstores, and we hope you do too.
Disclaimer
The episode transcripts are auto-generated, and while all efforts are made to ensure their accuracy, there may be some instance of incorrect spelling and/or errors in the accuracy.
www.killcitypodcast.com.au
This is part two of our conversation with Haley Scrivener. We hope you enjoy it.
Speaker 1The Kill City podcast acknowledges the traditional custodians of the lands we're on. Here in Melbourne, that's the Wurundjeri Woi Worong people of the Kulin Nation. We honour their deep connection to storytelling, a tradition carried across more than 2,000 generations. Pay our respects to elders past, present, and emerging, and we extend that acknowledgement to First Nations people listening today.
SpeakerIt drops you straight into the tension between Finn and Daphne. So I'm curious, I mean, we I'm a bit fascinated by first lines, first pages, first chapters. Oh, me too. So I'm curious, when did that line arrive for you? And was that the spark that kicked off the book, or did it come to you once you'd sort of worked out the dynamic?
Speaker 2Yeah, my beginnings are never written at the beginning, almost never. There were a lot of factors that went into this beginning. One was uh Patricia Highsmith, the American suspense writer, who I love for many reasons. I love her writing, but also she was just such a delightful misanthrope. And if you read about her life, um she was kind of an equal opportunity hater of everyone except her snails and her cats. Um, and she drove at least one woman to suicide. Like she is like not messing around, Patricia Highsmith. Um, she wrote The Talented Mr. Ripley and um Strangers on a Train, you know. Um, but she has this thing in her book uh on writing and plotting suspense fiction where she encourages you to have a primitive opening. And what that means is whoever is kind of in the opening, we don't want to we don't we shouldn't need to know, oh, this is Sally, and Sally has kind of this going on, and like she doesn't really talk to her dad anymore because of this, and like you you don't want to do all that set dressing. What you want is one, two, or three people in a situation that you can kind of instantly comprehend without needing to know too much about their backstory. So in Girl Falling, what I really wanted was we've got one character who's clearly in love with one character, they're like girlfriend and girlfriend, and then there's this character who clearly knows Finn a lot better than she knows Magdoo, and there's some they're clearly old friends, but there's clearly something weird going on. There's something weird in the dynamic, something weird in the vibe. And um I think you can kind of comprehend that without knowing the backstory of the fact that you know Finn and Daphne both lost their sisters to suicide in high school, and you know, that Magdoo is an international student um studying psychology. You know, you don't need to know all of those things to kind of understand that something is going on. Um, and so that's one sort of factor. And another thing I was really thinking about a lot when I wrote that opening was uh the opening of The Secret History, which is sort of embarrassing to tell on myself because it's never going to be as good as Jonathan, right? But I I really love the frame to that novel. And you know, um Richard Um Papen says, at one time, you know, in my life, there were any number of stories I could have told. This is now the only story I can tell, words to that effect. And he also introduces this idea of I didn't used to believe in the fatal flaw, but now I do, and mine is that I value the aesthetic above all else. And it just kind of enters this storytelling mode. Like Richard Papen wants to tell you what has happened here, and he also, you know, spends in the first paragraph the fact that he and his mates have murdered someone, like it's this incredible, you know. Um a lesser writer would hold that, hold that back, and that would be kind of the mystery, but Donna just gives it to you all at the beginning. Um, but this idea of, and you know, what I took from that is Finn sort of tells you, I need to sort of tell this story and figure out the point at which I have gotten it so wrong. Like where, you know. And for me, the whole book is really narrated. I picture Finn standing on the cliff a week after Magdoo has fallen, and she's going through everything that's happened, and so the whole book is really narrated from that point in time, even though that's kind of impossible because it's thousands of words. I think it's a 75,000-word book. But in my head, that's where she's standing the whole time, and she's kind of telling the story to herself and to the reader. And Isabel Carmody had this great line, the Australian fantasy writer, that in the third person you'll you're dealing with a character who has a story that that kind of you as the author want to tell about them, and in the first person you have a character who wants to tell you their story. And that Finn was definitely the latter. So yeah.
SpeakerUm also, and we talk about this, we've talked about this already, without ever wanting to spoil anything on this podcast. It does take some remarkable twists at the end of the form. Um so without giving anything away, um, so how early in the process did you start thinking about the end?
Speaker 2It is an ending that many people have told me made them throw the book across the room, and uh to which I respond, excellent, wonderful, completely the point, exactly what I wanted you to feel. And one thing I will say, as much as I don't know much about the characters, I don't know anything about what's going to happen in the middle of the story, one thing that has been true for every book I've written, I say every book, there's two books, and I'm working on a third, but I always seem to have the final image of the book. So, and and that and implied in that is kind of the ending. So in Dirt Town, I I kind of I knew who had killed Esther, and I knew kind of what had happened, and I could picture it, I could see this road outside of town. And in Girl Falling, I could see Finn standing on the cliff, and I realised what she the realization that she comes to at the end. So it's sort of a film, but also I guess I have that internal internality that you get with fiction. Um and with my third book, it was the image of a circus tent on fire. Um so in each case it's sort of as as little as I know about what the rest of the story is going to be, I do kind of have this lighthouse that I'm sort of heading for. Um, which is lucky because there's yeah, a lot of a lot of other things I sort of have to make up as I go along.
Speaker 1So who is, when you say your people, so who who provides you with the um support? Who gets you out of your trackies and you know lifts you on a on a tough day?
Speaker 2And I mean, I think it has to be said the Australian crime writing community is just incredibly warm. I'm yet to meet an asshole. Like I'm yet to meet someone that uh I wouldn't be excited to go to their launch or you know, and for whatever reason my friends just keep writing books that I really like. It's gonna be really awkward. Like it is it's gonna happen. I have so many writing friends now that someday someone's gonna publish a book that I don't like. Um, but in which case you always say, like, massive congratulations on the book. You know, I guess, you know, like it's still a it's still a feat. Any finished book is a feat. Um, but in in my immediate sort of life, I I'm really lucky that, you know, one of my earliest readers lives literally next door to me and will you know kind of have me over for tea or whiskey anytime I want to complain or talk about the book or um and there are people that I've been writing with since um since Dirt Town was a twinkle in my eye kind of thing. And those are really precious because you just know that they um they know how hard you've worked, but they also know what you're capable of, and they're you know, but then I also just love meeting new people. I love going to a festival and just feeling like being excited to see what's what's coming out and and sort of overwhelmed by trying to keep track of it all. Um, you know, and it's it is a a a strange time to debut, you know. We've never had more books kind of, you know, on a given it wasn't and it wasn't until the day Do It Town came out that I had any idea how many books come out on a given sort of Tuesday, you know, like it's really confronting.
SpeakerI um I say this quite regularly on this podcast to the point where I'm gonna start editing myself out at some point. But when we first started this, I was genuinely convinced that I had a really good handle on just this genre. Yeah, just this one. I wasn't sort of expecting, you know, to know all the things about all the other genres. Uh it has been a really confronting realization that if I thought I knew this, but the reality is I was under it by a really long way. And it's it's such a healthy industry at the moment, and again, this is another story I talked about early. I remember 25 years ago um having walked around the Kill City bookshop in Melbourne by a really diligent, helpful staff member that helped me try and find all the Australian crime books, and it was a uh it was a pretty short walk because there just wasn't that much. We looked at the look. Um yeah, so to compare the two time periods is um yeah, it's remarkable now. So it does which are put a lot of uh uh things on our TBR list and uh good problem to have it.
Speaker 2It is it is a very great problem to have.
Speaker 1Absolutely. And I um I liked what you said about um meeting new people in the room always in terms of having um you know these new experiences and getting to um catch up and you know um meet new authors. Um, particularly um sort of on the flip side, I guess you also have the opportunity, particularly at festivals and things, to actually meet your readers. Now you've already spoken about how you've got the camp that loved Dirt Town and you've got the camp that love Girl Falling, and goodness only knows what people are going to think about with book three, which we will get to very soon. Um, but is there anything we just love hearing stories if there's been any particularly um lovely or unusual things that you know readers have shared with you after reading sort of one of or both of your books?
Speaker 2Well, I remember at the time it didn't feel lovely, but as I reflect on it, I think it's actually a sign that the book has really stayed with this person. I was doing a um, it was kind of like a Zoom book club, so I was zooming in, you know, it was my Friday night, I'll zoom in, you know, this will be great, I'll get to chat to some readers. And there was one woman in the book club who just could not tolerate the ending of Dirt Town. She said, I need you to change it. And I said, Well, it's already been published in in several languages, and and like I I'm sorry, but I actually quite like the ending. And in the end, you know, and it just it like it just kept going. It was very cyclical, like there was sort of no escape and and no one was kind of helping me or extricating me from. And I and in the end I went, I think that ending just really has stayed with her, and I will take that as a kind of um you know, because we want certain things to happen in stories, not realizing that that level of character engagement and that level of desire for things to work out well for the characters is a sign that those characters feel real to us. Um, so yeah, I that when I look back on it, I go, okay, I think that I think we can chalk that up as a positive.
Speaker 1I I think that is a pretty cool compliment, actually, that she loved it so much that she needed you to change it to the way she needed that ending to happen.
Speaker 2I probably could have found an old word doc version of it and just and then everyone was fine and everything was great and they all lived happily ever after.
SpeakerYou've said a couple things tonight that has has piqued my interest. Um obviously Dirt Town and Girl Falling are really different books, and then you talked about a novel that was going to be set in space, which is again quite different without knowing too much about your your new book. Should we expect that you will try and find something different, like really vastly different every time a book comes out?
Speaker 2I think I kind of reserve the right to do whatever. You know, I do think that readers even though there's definitely a world where like we you know, there are there are authors that I go, oh good, I'm gonna get this kind of experience and I'm excited about that, and that's very comforting. But I think at the end of the day, readers want authors to be doing what gets them out of bed and what kind of excites them. And it seems to be that I I seem to need to kind of start at zero. I mean, I keep killing people, so I think that's something, like that has to count for something, right? People keep getting murdered, so surely that that's sort of enough of a through line. Um, but I think again, it's if you want characters that I have kind of um cried over, and if you want emotional sincerity, and you want um that su that a crime has happened, then I hope that you'll kind of follow me wherever it is that I'm that I'm going. Um and I will say I am I am leaving Australia with the next book, which um might sort of disqualify me from this Australian crime running podcast, but it's exciting.
SpeakerNo, you you live here, so that's okay.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's all that's all we need, yeah.
SpeakerCan we tease a little bit out of you on the new book or are we?
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean it's it's due in December, so um I just I I'm so I have been very superstitious in the past about talking about things, but this book I've talked about a bit just because it is a book that I have wanted to write for a long time. It's based in my mother was born in a travelling circus in the UK in the early 60s, um, which means that her parents, my grandparents, were circus performers um who had her and then her sister before and then they they left the UK, left the circus and moved to Australia. But I've always been fascinated by that sort of before time. My mother describes, you know, chimpanzee changing her nappy, she had a pet jaguar named Fluffy, um, you know, like these things that are just not what a normal childhood is kind of like. And my grandmother would do um aerial work, and she was also a showgirl, she was a dancer, you know, very beautiful, she sewed her own costumes, and my grandfather worked with chimpanzees mainly, but he also worked with polar bears, uh, tigers. Um he was really uh someone who loved his animals, but it's also interesting with the the contemporary sensibility around animals and circuses, and so I don't know, they've just it's always been a period of time and a kind of a kind of life that I have wanted to explore, but probably just didn't feel up to for my you know first or second book. And then it came to the third book, and I thought, okay, maybe I'm I'm gonna try and tackle tackle this. So it will be set in the late 50s and it will be set in the UK, and it is set in a travelling circus, and someone does get murdered. So does that seem uh like enough to go on?
Speaker 1Absolutely. That's all I need. When in December is it coming?
SpeakerI'm I'm still the whole getting a nappy change by a chimpanzee and I could.
Speaker 2It's horrifying, and you hear about chimpanzees, you know, ripping people's faces off and just you know, you just wouldn't let a baby be near one. Um, but yes, it's uh it was definitely a different kind of kind of life. And I'm very interested in both how hard it was as a lifestyle and also how much meaning um because my grandmother's still alive and she taught I I didn't realise until I was I I sort of have been talking to her while writing this book and interviewing her and recording um uh you know, talking to her. And I didn't realise how meaningful it was in terms of it was her art form, like it was what what she she did that other people couldn't do and the the sort of meaning and pride that that kind of came from that. And I don't because I had always grown up hearing how hard it was in that kind of you know, oh yeah, you walked 50 feet in the snow while I like hung upside down um from my ankles and then picked like then and then from my teeth and then span around, you know, like you just can't compete with that, right? Like so um it was also cool to realise that I'm just writing a story about um I actually see a lot of similarities to to to writing a novel. Like it's it's kind of painful, it hurts to do. You question why am I doing this? It takes a lot of time to become proficient in it in it. But then when you have that moment that someone sees what you're doing, um, you know, everything is illuminated, I think.
SpeakerSo Wow, I am looking very much looking forward to this. This is um excellent. I'm glad there's uh there's a date and uh some light at the end of the tunnel. Um now.
Speaker 2And I should say due in December to my publisher, how how many edits because we have established that I am the worst writer in Australia and it will take many, many rounds of structural edits to get there. But you know, hopefully next year, hopefully 2027.
SpeakerYeah. Oh, so not yeah, cool.
Speaker 2So I'm so like due in a Word document form to my publisher, yeah.
Speaker 1Okay, we've we've mentioned how big our TBR is, so it's okay. So that's okay.
SpeakerSo uh let's shift gears a little bit um and end with a couple of lighter questions. Um whose writing brain would you borrow for a day just to see how it works?
Speaker 2Oh, I am a massive fan of the Norwegian writer Karl Uver Kanausko or Nausgarj. He wrote the epic six-part autobiographical series My Struggle. Um I would love for writing to be so kind of he is so prolific. Like he seems to be, and I I find him fascinating. I read everything that he writes, I love his fiction, I've read all six of those books at least three times. Um He's not someone I would necessarily want to have coffee with. I don't think we would like each other, but I I just love his ability to kind of almost capture something about what it is to be alive as he is living it. Like, you know, because through the the series of six books, it's like his relatives start suing him for the earlier books, and by the end his wife has left him for the things he's written in the earlier books, and and I'm so slow, and it takes me so long, and I I'm so bound to fiction because I I do think it's what I do best, and whenever I, you know, but the the ability to kind of um reflect on life so quickly. You know what, it's the same kid who couldn't like fill a journal as a little kid, like he just seems like someone who could just you know fill a thousand journals, and I um I'm envious, I'm envious of that.
Speaker 1I like that.
Speaker 2I'd also like to hang out in Jonathan Tart's brain so I would know like when the next book is coming.
Speaker 1Oh my goodness, wouldn't we all like how long? You said you're you know, you said you might be a slow writer, but goodness gracious, you've got nothing on hair.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's we're overdue. Yeah, yeah.
SpeakerI keep um I keep periodically jumping online thinking I'm gonna be different and because I'd originally there'd been some speculation that it was gonna be last year or this year, and now the speculation is next year and there's not a single thing.
Speaker 2Um but I also love there's nothing until there's a book, you know, and then we get the book and we're like, thank you, Donna, and you know.
SpeakerYeah. No, I um cannot wait.
Speaker 2And I'm a big rereader, so whenever I you know, you can always go back and just I don't think I think um a little friend doesn't get no The Little Friend, sorry, Donna Tart's The Little Friend doesn't get enough love.
SpeakerNo.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think it's it's 'cause people, you know, know the Goldfinch 'cause it was made into a movie and they know secret history because it's like the dark academia novel or whatever. But yeah.
SpeakerYeah, and it is a r still a remarkably good book, The Little Friend as well. Like it um I have some very, very vivid vivid memories of reading that and yeah, it's that really stuck with me. Particular scenes that I'm still like yeah, that are still there. So um that will be a highly anticipated, well it is a highly anticipated um next book because this is her biggest segue going a little bit getting off track, but this is her biggest gap now because this is about it's been tw 12 or 13 years, hasn't it?
Speaker 2Yeah, and usually they're ten.
SpeakerYeah.
Speaker 2I really feel like I brought the the tone of the Australian Crimewriting podcast down by by qu um citing on Norwegian and then an American. I'm so sorry.
Speaker 1This is no, don't apologize at all. This is why we love these questions, because this is how we just understand, you know, a little bit more about how your brain works and what you know what what's what's in interesting and exciting in your world. So the next one, hopefully, sorry, Leigh, were you gonna No no I just no no nothing um no you mentioned Donatarian?
SpeakerI just I I resisted the temptation to sort of pick at the thread then, but I couldn't I couldn't resist around.
Speaker 1We we love going down a rabbit hole though, so that's with um yes, we don't we don't have particular limits at all. So but if we get back on track, the other question we love asking all of our authors who come on is if you were stranded on a desert island, which Australian crime fiction novel would you take with you for company?
Speaker 2Ooh, I should have prepared and I didn't. Just one. Just one. Can I take a series? Is that have you let people do that before?
Speaker 1We're just gonna let you, because you're the first one with us.
Speaker 2I would take Danuka Mackenzie's uh The Torrent Taken and Tipping Point because on a desert island that I just wanna like her her stories just so immersive and they so kind of I don't know, they're kind of about daily life in some ways, like they are about the grind of like trying to make things happen, and yet I always feel transported out of my life, and I just they're such a cracking series, and because I have a very bad memory, I could just circle through the three, I think.
SpeakerAnd look, I think we can just jump ahead and just sort of give her publisher an idea for uh Kate Miles Omnibus. So I think that's okay.
Speaker 2Yeah, we can if we can get into one. I could just like, yeah, it's um or cellotate them together, you know. That'll count. Definitely absolutely.
SpeakerUm all right, so before and before we let you escape, um one last thing. It's just a fun way for our listeners to get to know you a bit more beyond your book. So we like to call it our rapid fire, quicken the curious round of questions. So I'll run through a quick list of either or choices and just go with your first instinct. Um you ready?
Speaker 2Mm-hmm.
SpeakerOkay. Locked room mystery or small town secret?
Speaker 2Oh, I've got to go to small town secret.
SpeakerCold case or fresh crime scene?
Speaker 2Cold case.
SpeakerAmateur sleuth or seasoned cop?
Speaker 2Seasoned cop.
SpeakerA twist ending or slow burn?
Speaker 2Slow burn.
SpeakerUh who did it, how they did it, or why they do it?
Speaker 2Yeah, why done it for me.
SpeakerUm Agatha Raisin or Vera?
Speaker 2Vera.
SpeakerUh creepy neighbor or charming stranger?
Speaker 2Creepy neighbour.
SpeakerRed herrings or straight clues?
Speaker 2Red herrings.
SpeakerUh rural noir or coastal crime?
Speaker 2Well, coastal crime's fun.
SpeakerUh to escape the scene of the crime, Ford or Holden?
Speaker 2Uh Prius? Is that a Is a 2009 Toyota Prius an option?
SpeakerIt can be.
Speaker 2It's very fuel efficient.
SpeakerUm crime solved by the family dog or the nosy next door neighbour?
Speaker 2I've got to go nosy next door neighbour.
SpeakerUh unreliable narrator or rock solid witness?
Speaker 2Unreliable narrator.
SpeakerUh crime boss or lone wolf villain?
Speaker 2Lone wolf.
SpeakerFinal showdown or the quiet reveal?
Speaker 2Mm. Final showdown.
SpeakerAnd the last one, Mrs. White in the kitchen with a candlestick or Colonel Mustard in the bathroom with the wrench?
Speaker 2Colonel Mustard every time. Very stylish man.
Speaker 1Wow, so why are the stylish ones always the murderers, though? Oh, I love that, Halle. Thank you so much. You didn't even blink when we just do a few more curly ones at you. It's awesome.
Speaker 2Well, and they're sort of contradictory in some ways, but I just you've got to go, you've got to treat it like a psychological exam, you know, and just kind of go with whatever.
SpeakerWell, consider yourself officially inducted into the Kill City Rapid Fire Hall of Fame. Uh it's very exclusive. We just made it up for this episode, so well done. Um so thank you very much. That was great.
Speaker 1Oh, thank you so much. Look, it's been so much fun chatting with you today, and um, you know, it was just a delight hearing um all the all the tips and tricks that you shared and um, you know, understanding um how your brain ticks a little bit, which was great. Um, and we absolutely love talking to you. Thank you.
Speaker 2Oh, thanks for having me. I hope I didn't complain too much.
SpeakerThank you. No, thank you for being um incredibly generous with your stories and your answers today. Um we really look forward to the next novel um when it does come out. Um so yeah, thank you very much for being so generous and open with your answers.
Speaker 2Thanks so much for having me, and thank you for supporting Australian crime. I mean, I think one thing that makes this genre is its readers, um, and is this sense of community that seems to form around, you know, Death and Mayhem, which I think is just absolutely wonderful. I think it's such a wonderful thing that you're doing.
SpeakerNo, we um we love it. So uh it's it's been so much fun. So no, thank you very much. We've we've been indebted to all the writers that have um come on the show and um and all the people that listen to the show, obviously. Um, and so for everyone that's listening, we've we've popped all of Haley's books from today's chat in the show notes so you can dive in whenever you like. Uh and if you'd like to keep up with us, you can follow the Kill City podcast on Facebook and Instagram, which uh that's where we drop clues about upcoming episodes and the occasional suspicious-looking book launch.
Speaker 1Um That's us for this episode. Thanks for listening to the Kill City Podcast. If you've got fan mail, burning questions, or a crime writer that you would like us to grill next, send them our way because we'd love to hear from you. Uh but for now we're putting the bookmark back in the book till next time, and we'll see you then.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
In Competition
Sean & Jim
He Read She Read
He Read She Read
Writer's Routine
Dan Simpson
Stories Behind the Story with Better Reading
Better Reading PodcastLiterary Anything
City of Marion Libraries
Talking Aussie Books
Claudine Tinellis