Kill City
Australian crime fiction is our M.O. The Kill City podcast is all about Australian crime writing, crime books and the Australian crime writing industry.
Tune in for author interviews, catch up on the latest industry news and book releases, and everything else happening in the Australian crime fiction scene.
Kill City
Hayley Scrivenor in the spotlight - Part One
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode Helen and Leigh speak to Hayley Scrivenor.
Hayley shares insights into her writing process, character development, and the evolution of her novels 'Dirt Town' and 'Girl Falling'. We discover how her background, research approach, and love for place shape her compelling stories.
Hayley Scrivenor shares her journey as a writer, the creative process behind her novels, and insights into the Australian crime writing scene. Discover how she crafts her stories, the importance of community, and her upcoming projects.
Find Hayley's books on Booktopia
Booktopia Affiliate Program
The Kill City Podcast is a part of the Booktopia Affiliate Program, meaning that when you purchase a book from Booktopia using one of the above the links, we get a small commission. Or as they'd say in the crime world, a kick back!
At the Kill City Podcast we love celebrating and promoting the work of Australian writers, publishers and bookstores, and we hope you do too.
Disclaimer
The episode transcripts are auto-generated, and while all efforts are made to ensure their accuracy, there may be some instance of incorrect spelling and/or errors in the accuracy.
www.killcitypodcast.com.au
The Kill City podcast acknowledges the traditional custodians of the lands we're on. Here in Melbourne, that's the Wurundjeri Woi Worong people of the Kulin Nation. We honour their deep connection to storytelling, a tradition carried across more than 2,000 generations. Pay our respects to elders past, present, and emerging, and we extend that acknowledgement to First Nations people listening today.
SpeakerHi Helen, good to see you. How are you today?
Speaker 2I'm very well, thanks, Leigh, and I'm super excited because today we're joined by the awesome Haley Scrivener.
SpeakerWe are indeed. Hi Haley, thanks so much for joining us today.
Speaker 2Thanks so much for having me, Leigh and Helen. I'm really happy to be here. Thanks so much. It's so nice to meet you. And if it's all right with you, I'd like to kick off by giving our listeners the quick version of your bio because there's a lot for us to unravel. So you burst onto the scene with your debut Australian crime novel Dirt Town in 2022, which quickly became a number one Australian bestseller. It was then published internationally and released in the US's, I think, Dirt Creek, where it became a USA Today bestseller. Now your book went on to sweep an remarkable list of awards. It won the IBIA General Fiction Book of the Year, the CWA ILP John Cree's The New Blood Dagger, and the Lambda Literary Award for LGBTQ mystery. It was also shortlisted for the Nick Kelly Award for Best Debut Fiction, the Indie Book Awards for Best Debut Fiction, the Matt Richel Award for the New Rush of the Year, and both adapted awards, the Adult Crime Fiction and Debut Crime Book. And it was also a finalist for the ITW Thriller Award for Best Novel. Insert pause to be able to take another breath at this point. Then your second novel, Girl Falling, landed in 2024, winning the 2025 People Choice Danger Award and also earning another Lambda Literary Award nomination. Wow, what a great start. So you're based in Willingong on Darrowwell in the country in New South Wales. You hold a PhD in creative writing from the University of Willingong. And before becoming a full-time novelist, you worked as a festival director. Now these days you're deeply involved in the writing community, teaching, mentoring, and running workshops through organisations like Writing New South Wales and the Faber Writing Academy. Wow. Before we start talking about your books, I need to know: do you ever get any downtime? And if you do, what does it actually look like for you? I really want to know that you do get to spend some time in your trackies and your ug boots sort of binge watching something completely mindless on TV.
Speaker 1Well, I can put your mind to rest, Helen. There's definitely a lot of, I mean, all of my working life is spent in my track pants pretty much, which is definitely a wonderful thing to kind of realize and to enjoy. But I am actually someone who does not function without turning my brain off at the end of the day. And I actually, one of the great sadnesses of my life is that if I try and read before bed, I can't fall asleep. So it's like my brain, if I try if I if I try and do any kind of work after five or six at night, my brain just kind of refuses to shut down. So even reading fiction, and and I guess this was when I was younger too, but it's certainly since become fiction's kind of become my day job. When I go to read a book, it's like my brain gets too excited. So I have to, I have to actually um embrace uh really winding down at the end of the day. So um I watch a lot of sort of stand-up comedy because there's not a lot of narrative to it, or I watch, yeah, I watch something that just completely sort of I've just been away on a one-week residency with the Mudge Mudgy Readers Festival, which was wonderful. And I um was staying in this Airbnb, there was only free-to-air TV, and I ended up watching like an embarrassing amount of below deck. So, you know, just do not worry that that I'm sort of at working at an intellectual kind of lather at all times, because it's just it's just not what's what's happening.
Speaker 2That makes me feel so much better, and seriously, but below deck is um has just gold, a lot of comedy gold, actually.
Speaker 1I'm not sure they think it's fun, just it is weirdly compelling. I'm like, there's such long episodes and there's so many of them, and I'm like, why do I keep coming back? You know, but they just kept being on Seven Bravo or whatever the free to and you know, you get the ads as well. It's like um yeah. So perfect recipe for turning up your brain, isn't it? Yes, perfect downtime.
SpeakerSo is that to say you you never write at night?
Speaker 1I have written about a paragraph of any of my books in the evening. I can distinctly remember it was something to do with um the cop in my first book, and I had a thought. Like I might I might write down an idea, like it might be something like, Oh, I've realized her mother um like her mother should come in in that scene or whatever. So I might jot that down. And a lovely reader once actually gave me a tip on little pens that light up. So I have a little pen by my bed, so when it's dark, it's got a red light in it, and you can get a post-it note and and the pen lights up, so you don't you're not making lots of light pollution. Um, which is good because I want to roll over and go back to sleep. But in terms of like sitting down at my laptop, yeah, I've written about a paragraph in I've been writing um pretty much full-time since 2016.
SpeakerWow, that's I wonder if we were to survey a hundred writers. I wonder how many of them would say um they don't write at night. That's um that's quite incredible. Like, I think it's great that you can compartmentalize it on the other hand and and have it as a very functioning day procedure um or process. But um yeah.
Speaker 1It's just everything I've I I anything I've tried to write at night just hasn't been any good. And I think writers get very superstitious about these things. So I remember trying to do uni assignments and things, and just nighttime was is not when I'm at my at my best. Um it's that when I first wake up, and particularly with fiction, when you first wake up and before you've talked to anyone and before you've gone on the internet and checked anything, or you know, um just kind of trying to stay in that space for as long as possible in the morning. Um, that is where I write 99% of my books is in that sort of 7am to kind of lunchtime space.
SpeakerOh, that's amazing. Well, now that you've let us in on some of your secrets, um let's talk about your first novel, um Dirt Town. So quick rundown. We're in a small rural community in New South Wales where 12-year-old Esther Bianchi goes missing. Um we see the fallout through the local kids, uh, Ronnie, her best mate, and Lewis, who's hiding what he saw, and then through the adults, uh, the kids' families, and the detective who's on the case, um, Sarah Michaels. Uh, as the investigation unfolds, the town's secrets start cracking open, and everyone's carrying something they'd rather keep buried. Um and look, we gave this book a big shout out in our episode on best Australian crime debut, because it really is.
Speaker 1You did, and flattery will get you everywhere.
SpeakerUm and I like I absolutely loved it. I'm actually, it's sitting here next to me, and I'm due to reread it actually. Um you nailed the emotional truth of rural town under pressure, and you know the way you blend character-driven suspense um with emotional depth for for such for a first novel, like it it was amazing, and it genuinely blew me away. And one of the things that makes Dirt Town so distinctive is the way you tell the story. Instead of centering the mystery around the detective, you build it through the five different points of view, including that incredible collective we voice from the town's children. What drew you to multi-perspective structure and and how tough was it to sort of pull it off on the page?
Speaker 1Oh well, thank you. Firstly, it's always lovely to hear nice things about your book. And I I'm deep in book three at the moment, so it's nice to remember with some part of my brain that I can actually write and that like books that you know, because I remember Dirt Town was not just, you know, my first novel, it was really my first serious attempt at writing, and I spent six years working on that book. Um, so where some people have a book in the bottom drawer, you know, I just kind of kept returning to this idea, and there was a version of that book that was totally told from that collective voice you're talking about, which I always imagined as a bit like a um a Greek chorus and a traditional Greek play. So anyone who doesn't know, you know, in old Greek plays, you would um have this group of people come on and they would be like villagers in the town or some kind of um they would be in the in the story world, but they would sort of sing about what was going on in the story. So they'd sort of say, Oh, woe is us, you know, our hero isn't going to make it. It's a very, you know, ancient form of storytelling. And I loved this idea of taking that, but making it a bunch of kind of daggy Australian school kids in the town where I grew up. There was just something that really tickled me about that idea. And so that's really where the book began. Um, and over time other points of view began to come in. So you mentioned Ronnie, who's the um basically the chorus I realised they were singing such as it was, because a girl had gone missing from their town. And once I knew that, I sort of went about building a world where yeah, we meet her best friend Ronnie, who is really determined to kind of find her best friend and bring her home, which is super sad because we know from the first page, so it's not a spoiler, that Esther is dead, like Esther is not going to be coming home. And then I sort of um I remember adding Lewis because there had always been a boy that the chorus kind of sang about who had seen Esther on the day she went missing but was too afraid to tell anyone for reasons of his own, which become apparent through the book. And then I added in the mother Constance, who is obviously desperate for her only daughter to come home. And then the very last character to kind of come in through the gate before I swung the door closed and said, Okay, no more points of view, was Detective Sergeant Sarah Michaels. And she's um she's ultimately the one that unpicks the mystery, but it isn't a typical police procedural in that way, you know. She is one of, I think, she's very important, but she is one of five ways that we kind of move through the story.
SpeakerSo um all these characters feel like they've lived lives before we've we've met them. So what's the first thing you would need to know about a character before you can write them and um you know, to to get them in? Obviously, in this instance you had the five of them. So what was the first thing you had to know about each of them before um you could write them?
Speaker 1It's a great question, and I think some people really have a knack for character, like they are can very quickly in four or five kind of you know, when you see an amazing drawer and with just four or five lines, they can really create the shape of a person who feels very embodied. I'm not that person. I am on the floor with my Crayolas kind of spread out, and I have almost no idea who these people are. Um the the one exception is maybe, and because it was my first book, you know, I I based the character of Ronnie, um, who was a chubby, no-it-all, very much on myself as a kid. Um just because it was so uh character creation was so difficult, I thought if I can just kind of tether her to me in some ways, like that will make it easier. Um But really the way the way that I come to character is that I just spend a lot of time and I write a lot of stuff that I don't use. Um and it's sort of, it would be laughably kind of, you know, and and when people say I'm good at character, it's really meaningful and I really love it because it's definitely not easily done. You know, it it is that I just sit there and I and it's sort of, you know, oh, do they like bananas? I don't know, do they like banana? You know, it's like every decision kind of has to be made. I'm not very good at cutting to the quick in that way. But one thing I have learned over writing more than one book now is that every character will have some way of looking at the world that is probably doing them a little bit of damage, like some misapprehension they have about the way the world works, or something they have misunderstood that is probably gonna be pressed upon by the plot. So in Dirttown, for example, Ronnie is an incredibly naive character, I quickly realised, because I was a really gullible kid, I would believe anything. Um, and once I sort of realised that about her, I realised how the plot was kind of um gonna, to be frank, do pretty terrible things to her sense of of kind of that everything was gonna be alright and that Esther was gonna come home, I guess. And then yeah, I just went through that process with every character. I s I put them in different situations. Um I kind of write various cheat sheets for myself as I'm trying to figure out who they are, but it does often come to what what is what is the kind of in the the the chink in the way they the you know in the glass that they're looking at the world through.
SpeakerWell, I mean the kids' chapters are some of the most powerful in the book, and especially Esther and her best mates, um Ronnie and Lewis. You you do write them with such clarity and emotional truth. Um you mentioned that one of them is a a loose connection to yourself when you're younger. Any other um any of the other characters drawn from people that you'd known from childhood or Yeah, it's interesting.
Speaker 1I sort of joke that all my characters are me, even the ones and often the ones that you would think are the least me are kind of the most me because when the bibliography uh when the biography, sorry, is not um sorry, telling I said bibliography, um, when the biography is not uh as similar, I feel like I can put more into that character in a way. Um so you know, luckily I just have enough neuroses to go around that I can kind of liberally assign them to everyone. So in in Dirt Town, for example, Lewis, who is a young boy, um, I definitely gave him my memories of growing up, and I wouldn't have I wouldn't have used that word queer, but growing up in a small country town feeling that there was something about me that would not be welcome if it was found out. And that is such a big part of Lewis's story. But then also when we look at a character like Detective Sergeant Sarah Michaels, who is an out-cop and is kind of doing as well as an out-cop in the early 2000s could expect to do. Like she is is respected by her partner who she works with, so when she's out on the road, um, I really feel like she gets to be sort of free-floating from those bigger structures that probably would have made life hard. Um, so yeah, I don't know if that answers your question, but I, you know, and even yeah, Constance is a character whose daughter is missing, and I remember my brother used to wander off a lot, and I would just kind of when I was riding her, I would sort of, because in the time that Dirt Town is happening, you know, Constance is having the worst week of her life, pretty much. And so I just would try and tune into that emotional register of like what did it feel like when we didn't know where Chris was, which happened way more than it should have, because he's yeah, he would just bolt. Um yeah, so that the you you kind of find those tuning forks, those ways of entering, but it's often finding an emotional connection that I can make and then kind of elaborating from there.
Speaker 2No, that sounds amazing. And look, I'm gonna add to the wee chorus and um say how much I love Dirt Town. Actually, I do I do a top ten list of books that I've read every year across all genres, and um Dirt Town definitely made was high up in my top ten that that first year I I read it, and I have to admit it did break my heart, might have been a bit of a wreck at the end, but um it did make me want to go back and read it again. So I did read it again um as part of the research for this, and oh just just um just oh everything on the page, just just absolutely loved it's it's just the masterpiece.
Speaker 1But um, I love hearing people reread because you know you do sometimes I'll read a book and I'll go, oh, I'm pretty sure that was four years of someone's life, you know, and you put it down and with dirt town, like with all my writing, I write to be reread. I I you know there are certain things that you can't see until you've been through the story and come back, and yeah, so it's very satisfying to hear that you did that.
Speaker 2It's it was actually really fun to do it, I have to admit, because um I thought I remembered it quite well, but it was things like what you talked about because I hadn't realized the sophistication of the Greek chorus until I started doing the research and re and then reading it again and going, oh, that's what you were doing.
Speaker 1So I thought that's another compliment because you know, new, yeah. Yeah, it's the chorus is kind of like I said, it's a very old form of storytelling. So, in some ways, you know, and it's dangerous to get me talking about it because I did do my PhD on kind of um collective narration and and the this idea of the chorus, and I was really interested in it and still am. But actually, any good story sort of presents itself and kind of teaches you how to read it, right? And the goal is not that you feel that that these these very highfalutin things are happening. The goal is that you are you sort of you're not quite sure they seem to be this group of kids, they seem to be embodied, they certainly have physical experiences in the town, but then they also seem to be able to zoom up and above and see what's going on. And that's actually, you know, we we're very au fay with that kind of narrator, like Dickens or Austin, you know, we we we don't always question how how they come to be in the room and know what's sort of going on. So, you know, the goal is definitely not to make you work hard actually and to to let it sort of wash over you. But if people go digging for um, oh what is actually happening here? Like, where are they in position to the text? Like, I always enjoy that side of it too.
Speaker 2Absolutely, it's those layers. So that that is the advantage of having those books that you love so much that you do go back and you read them again because you can find something else in them. So thank you. I'm really interested in your research process, and I think you know talked about it a little bit because um there is something about how you know your books come together. But when you're starting a new book, so how do you actually approach research? Like, do you have a bit of a clear plan that you start with, or do you kind of look up things as you go, sort of at points in time?
Speaker 1So my dirty secret is always that I don't do as much research as I think people think I do, in terms of I am a big believer in, and it partly it comes down to how hard I find it to create characters anyway. So, what I what I have learned and what my process has kind of turned out to be is I will just put myself in the head of a person. So often research, you're doing it because, for example, you have, like I do, a cop character, and you want to get those facts right, you don't want to embarrass yourself, you don't want to sort of um you know bring the New South Wales police force into disrepute in some way by saying something that is that is wrong. But what I what I have realized is if if you embody that character, and and I had spent a lot of time getting to know Sarah, and then you think, what would this kind of person do in this situation? And you just sort of let yourself imaginatively play it out. Um, the really important step then is at a certain point where you really feel like, okay, this holds water, this seems to make sense. And it's scary to do that because you know that you might be riding yourself into a corner, you might have you know had a plot thing that hinges on something that is not possible, but then you go and you find someone, and the world is actually full of people that are really keen to tell you about the thing they know about. So in the case of Dirt Town, I found a former cop who had recently left the force who was willing to kind of read certain parts of it and and and answer questions. And and this sort of idea of imagining it and then checking it is really fruitful because the actually what you want it is for it to be emotionally believable above all things. And what can happen with me with research is that I learn some shiny new fact and I really want to kind of I really want to kind of wedge that in there, or I get lost down a rabbit hole of um, you know, and and not seen for weeks as I'm sort of and I did, you know, I sort of pulled up various guides on what to do when a child goes missing and um and things like that. But yes, that that process of really just thinking it through as the person, and then at the you know, once you really have a a what feels to you like something that really holds water, you you show it to someone, um, is is totally vibe. And I've had cops tell me, like, oh, your book is well, like Gary Disher said, Oh, your research, like you clearly did a lot of research, and I was like, Thanks, Gary.
Speaker 2That is that's a great book. Yeah, that's an endorsement.
Speaker 1So um, yeah, so I I think that it's worth putting out there that there are different ways of kind of approaching the material. Um I think maybe it does come down to wanting to keep the reader. I think was it John Gardner who said, you know, the dream must be vivid and continuous. Like that's what a novel should do. And so I want you to stay in the dream and I want nothing that will pull you out of that. But what seems to work best for me is approaching it emotionally rather than factually.
Speaker 2Right, I see. Well, that's interesting. So have you ever actually fallen into a research rabbit hole where actually you discovered something unexpected that I'd have actually shifted the direction of the book or a character?
Speaker 1Yeah, there was one thing that came up in Dirt Town where I found out that to be able to get DNA from hair, the root has to be attached. And there was a whole day of like wailing and gnashing of teeth that I had kind of made, you know, and I went, oh my god, why didn't I know this? I've completely written myself into a hole. And then I realized, oh, well, she could just tug the hair out, you know, like, oh, that's fine, you know, you I can sort of get around around that. So this is just in defense of my sort of research approach, but it, you know, I certainly lost at least one day in in kind of um feeling bad about that. But in terms of, I mean, the book I'm working on right now, I've learned some sort of fun facts about various animals, which has been fun. Um, but I think for me, the thing I have to research most I find really boring, which is often just like, how far away did I say this thing was for this thing, and like how long would it take for them to get, you know, it's almost um making sure. The practicalities of the world I've invented actually work out. So yeah, I'm revealing how bad I am at research, essentially. I get lost in like research holes. When I was doing my PhD, you know, I could read articles about ambiguity in the first person plural pronoun, you know, until the cows come home. But for whatever reason, with fiction, um I just have this real hunger. I'd rather just spend time with the person and and almost and so I've done things like imagine I was the person reading reading a certain book or piece of information, or yeah, but I I I find that when I just sit down and and I'm reading a lot about sort of um being, you know, what it was like being queer in the 50s and 60s. That's kind of my but I still just prefer to lit read people's sort of journals, things that weren't published at the time, so they're quite frank, um, and people's fiction, um, rather than really sitting down and reading like a textbook about it.
Speaker 2Okay, no, I I think that makes sense, and I don't think that's anything to be critical of yourself for, because I think the biggest testament I think it gives us as readers is we're not reading your books coming up with all the potholes because you have done your research and it's the practical research as well. So you're not going, oh no, but there's no way she could have run from there to there in this time and you know, made that happen. So I don't know, I think it's pretty cool.
Speaker 1Yeah, I sort of joke I should make a 3D model and put it somewhere I can see it because just spatial the day they were they covered spatial awareness in primary school, like I was clearly getting a feeling or something, like I was not, I just it's just not my strong suit. People will say, like, oh did you come from the east or the west? And I'll just go, Yes, I came from one of those directions. Or north or south. It couldn't, you know, I really when it says, Oh, drive 200 metres east, and I'm like, sorry, I could unless in Wollongong's pretty good because there's the ocean and then there's the mountains, so you know kind of north-south, east-west is alright. So I think that's why I've ended up here.
Speaker 2Yeah. I was trying to explain to my kids about the days before, like having the sat nav and stuff in your car, and you used to sit with like a um the Melways in Queensland on our lap trying to work out the I remember being forced to to you know decode that for an adult and was like, but do I turn left yet?
Speaker 1And I was like, this is too much responsibility. I'm 10 years old, this is too scary.
SpeakerI'm surprised I'm um I'm not still lost from having to navigate um using those old school mailways. And then I actually had a job where I actually had to direct people on public transport using like versions of that. I'm like, there's probably still people out there lost off the other directions, to be honest.
Speaker 2Apparently, I saved my parents from divorce by being the one that sat there with the mailways so that my mum and my dad didn't have to argue with each other while one drove and one tried to very badly navigate. Because one always started where they were going and the other one started with where they'd come from. So they never used to meet in the middle.
SpeakerThat's a very, very good segue because um I am a bit obsessed with how authors write about place, especially um Australian landscapes. Um we've got these really unique environments, and when someone captures them well, it really resonates with me. Um and Dirttown did that in a really striking way. So Dirton is based on the town you lived in when you were a kid at The Rock, about 20 minutes at Southwestern.
Speaker 1You've done your research, yes.
SpeakerSo, what was it about that place that made it the right foundation for your fictional town? And how much did your childhood memories sort of shape the way Dirt and feels on the page?
Speaker 1Well, I always like Yeah, I always like to apologize to the good people of The Rock because it's not their fault that I kind of went away and wrote a crime novel where a girl goes missing and horrible things happen in their town. But it really was that sort of um, you know, some people say write what you know, and I always like to counter that advice and say, write what you can give detail to. Because I think that's a lot more permissive in terms of I think you can if you want to, if it's your first novel and you want to write a novel set in space and you've really thought about how that would work and you can give detail to what a you know a some kind of space war would look like, great. But for me, the details that I had to hand and and a place that really seemed to be quite indelibly marked on me was that town. And it it's it's interesting because Dirt Town was not actually the book that I so I wrote Dirt Town as part of my PhD, like it was submitted um in in order to get my degree, um, and then I was lucky enough to sell it afterwards. But the the book I actually pitched to be able to get into the PhD um was going to be set in space. It was kind of gonna be this buddy comedy between two intergalactic kind of justice um they were these two detectives essentially kind of that were um that were kind of prosecuting various cases of cosmic injustice. So, you know, very similar to the end product that I always like to say that because you know people think um think that you you know you start a book and you kind of execute and then you know it's all about. Um but what I realized was that that book was sort of stalling. I'd had a couple chapters, and then I sat down because I wanted to write a short story, and I wanted to write something with this kind of plural voice, with this chorus voice, because that's what I was doing my PhD on. And it's worth saying the space book would have also had a like an us, um, an us voice. It would have been, you know, remember when we did this was kind of the the idea behind that novel. Um, remember that case we worked, basically. But then I sat down to write a short story because I thought, oh, I could get this published, it'd be good to have something to my name that's in this kind of chorus voice that's shorter than the book that I can publish sooner. And then I sat down and I tried and and I sat down to write, and it was just literally kids coming home from school, and there was just something about every time I reached for a detail, or I reached for some element of like, well, we came home this way and we did this, and when we got home, our mother made us wheat cordial, um, you know, in a jug whose patterns of freewheeling lemons and oranges had been rubbed away from use. You know, I was like, I could, they were just there, I could see it. Um, and I remember thinking, like I remember having friends who drank cordial and trying to break it to them that that's not what cordial should taste like. My my mum made cordial the proper way, like proper strength, and their mum made it at like 10% or whatever, and trying to break it to them that they'd been had. Just things like that, you know, things that felt true and that I knew about. And as I was doing that, I thought, well, why are all these kids talking about the way they they've got home today? Like what's so special about today? And that's when I realized that Esther Bianchi had gone missing, and that's actually the same time I realised what had happened to her, and so that's when it kind of became a crime novel, um, without me even realizing, because at from that point on I then had to sort of unpack for the reader, and you know, I knew that by the end of the book we should learn what had happened. Um, yeah, so it was really a process of kind of yeah, following what I could give detail to.
SpeakerUm so when you went back to The Rock as an adult, did it feel like the place you remembered from when you were a kid, or did it feel different to the one you'd turned into parts of the book?
Speaker 1It was so funny because I I did go back and I went back with a very dear friend, my mate, Linda Godfrey. We used to run the Writers Festival together, and I was like, this is really lovely. It seemed like such a sweet and lovely and wonderful place to grow up. And I went, what the hell was wrong with me? You know, um, but I think what it was is I remember I think anyone who's grown up anywhere, it's like wherever you landed, that was the the first place that you experienced isolation and and some kind of rejection or some kind of sense that you were out of place, or you know how kids always have this fantasy that they're adopted and that they're you know, um a lot of kids I know anyway, maybe I know a lot of neurotic types, but um, you know, so it was kind of like I that's why I say it's not the rock's fault. Like I just had all these big emotions and big feelings and was a kid who read a lot, and um, you know, I had I had lovely friends, but they were like horse girls, and so they would be doing their horsey stuff, and I would be on my um, you know, in in my house in town, just sort of being like, when am I gonna get out of here? So yeah, it was really funny going back and being like, This is lovely, like I would live here now, this is great. Right, you know, your kids could ride to school and like um and they wouldn't get that nothing bad would happen to them like happens in my in my book, you know. Um so yeah, I sort of I felt I I had felt a long lingering sense of guilt about what I did to the rock, but then my primary school librarian actually wrote to me on Facebook and said she really had enjoyed the book and thought I'd done a good job, and I decided to just stop worrying about that.
Speaker 2It's a really good day. I think that's fantastic. Alrighty, well, I'd like to now jump into your second novel, Girl Falling. And now this one um gave us a little bit of a shock because it's a bit pivot. So we've gone from gone from Dirt Town, which we kind of knew what we were sort of getting in terms of you know the way that uh we expect a crime novel to work. And um, Girl Falling is totally different, it's this really taught psychological crime thriller. Um, and to give people a quick sense of the storyline, the book centres on three young women: Finn, her childhood best friend Daphne, and Finn's girlfriend Magdu. And Finn and Daphne sort of have grown up together in a small Blue Mountains town, um, and they're tied together by tragedies that they um individually lived through when they were younger. Um, and again, you start the book with a whammy, so and it's not a spoiler to say that it does open with a shock because the three of them go rock climbing together, and um Magdu um falls from the cliff's edge to her death, and so the whole story kind of unfolds from there. But it's all about questioning whether it's a tragic accident, is it suicide, was it something more sinister? So I'm super curious what made you want to do this pivot and write a thriller for your second book, um, and then you know what was the brainwave or the spark um for this particular story?
Speaker 1Well, firstly, that was a very artful, there was very you know, you delicately stepped around some major um landmines there, so thank you, Helen, for that introduction.
Speaker 2I know we we try really hard not to spoil it. It's really really hard.
Speaker 1So Girl Falling is a very different book, and I think there is at my core something quite um oh, what's the word? Uh I really there is no interest for me if I know what I'm doing or if other people know what I'm doing. Like there's something quite sort of um recalcitrant's not the word. There's it's it's sort of I there's just I want to go somewhere where I don't know where that is, basically. And so um, and Dirt Town, it's worth saying, you know, kind of exploded in a way that I didn't anticipate. You know, it was every major publisher in Australia bit on it, it sold overseas, you know, it did all these um wonderful things. Um, you know, it won a CWA dagger, which I always tell people is not the Country Women's Association, it's actually the Crime Writers Association, it's the oldest and most prestigious uh crime writing organization in the world, you know, and so it was like, oh, okay, people like what I'm doing, but the problem was I was sort of already a year into writing the next thing, and it it was I knew it was going to be a very different book. And I think though that that's what saved me because it would have been a I I wouldn't have enjoyed writing Dirt Town to the dirt in, you know, like that just wouldn't have wouldn't have done it for me. Um and and I know for myself it comes back to how I make character, which is you would think that someone who struggles to find character would actually like the idea of a series or would, but there's something about the point of it is really how difficult I find it. It's it's sort of there is something in the time I have to spend with the characters that kind of makes makes the process worthwhile for me. So I really wanted to go somewhere different and and kind of do different terrain in every way, emotionally, you know, physically, it's very in a very different location. Um, but it's interesting because of course I'm still in all the characters. So I I and I sometimes think Finn is quite like a grown-up Ronnie in some ways. Um she's very credible, she's very quick to believe and to fall in love. Um, and if Dirt Town is a book about childhood, I really think that Girl Falling is a book about being in your early 20s when you're not sure who you are and you're kind of rubbing up against everything to figure out kind of where it ends and you begin, you know. Um, and it's it's a bit of an angsty book, and it's really about you know big first loves and and the kind of terrible things you do while you're trying to figure out who you are, um, and it's about bad bad friendship breakdowns and um yeah, it is a very different book.
Speaker 2Yeah, no, uh that's so interesting. Oh, how did I not figure that out about Finn being an adult Ronnie? See now I'm gonna have to go back and read it again.
Speaker 1Because Finn is a character very close to my, you know, in Dirt Town I had a suite of characters, but Finn is probably very close in well, she she is a real outdoorsy person, and that's definitely not I have done rock climbing and I have, you know, I was lucky in my 20s that I had a good, um, really great group of friends who were really into it and who took me out safely and and I would sort of just tag along, and as long as I didn't think too hard about what I was trying to do, I seemed to be able to do it. Um, but yeah, Finn is kind of closest to me in that I really wanted to write an like a bisexual character. I wanted to write a book set around the marriage equality plebiscite, so that's one another aspect of the setting of Girl Falling. Um, because I remember finding that incredibly upsetting. But it's also a love story, you know, in much more Dirt Town's a love story too, I guess, but I think Girl Falling I really wanted to explore, particularly through the kind of flashbacks we get to see how she and Magdoo meet and and and what it feels like to meet someone who makes you feel like a version of yourself that that you really like.
Speaker 2Yeah, no, and look, unpicking that, I think um the dual timelines and flashbacks that you say are so such a good way to be able to reveal different parts of the story. And the other thing I liked that you did differently for this one was of course is doing it in first person because it's basically we're hearing everything from Finn's viewpoint. So I was and and we kind of you know really get to understand, you know, these sort of relationships he has, particularly so Daphne's kind of this complicated friendship, and then Magdo's this sort of really intense, you know, romantic relationship. But but did you uh purposely pick it as first person so you were able to kind of explore things in that way that maybe if you'd done it in a different perspective you wouldn't have been able to?
Speaker 1I am definitely very I think a lot about point of view, and like I said, my f you know, I I looked at collective narrators in my first PhD, and it was also a way of just looking at I love when there is something unusual about the narration, or the narration in some way seems to speak to what the book is about. So, you know, Dirt Town is is kind of a story about what happens when you take one person away from a collective, so it seemed reasonable to tell that story using many different voices, one of which was a collective. And then girl falling is really a story of questioning your own sanity and questioning your own take on events, and really um, you know, the the book the the book opens with the the question why would my best friend want to destroy my life? And I I thought in first person we are in the claustrophobia of like not knowing the answer to that question and not knowing is Finn telling us everything that that or is Finn understanding what's happening correctly, you know, Magdoo is a psychology student and she tries to gently point out to Finn that maybe her relationship with Daphne, her best friend from high school, isn't the healthiest in the world. Um and because we're kind of strapped into to Finn's brain architecture, we we sort of um sometimes we can see just a little bit further than she can, but we're we're really I wanted that feeling of claustrophobia and of not ultimately knowing. Um so yeah, first person was very much baked into how I conceived of the book.
Speaker 2Yeah, I I um and and I think that really worked. And the other thing I was gonna pick up on which you beautifully um said already, was uh the piece around um you called it your bisexual book, and it's around you know these these characters and what they're going through. And I think one of my favourite lines I think is when you um because it's Finn's memories and experiences through the marriage equality plebiscite that we go through. And I think her mum called it the glorified survey. So just that the different but then hearing about sort of what Finn's perpet perspectives were and and experiences, just being able to have that as carry through the story, and I think you know, in the current um environment, which can be quite problematic, um having diversity of voice and representation just feels so much more important now, I think, more than ever. So is there something that you're able to share with us around how you approach writing in a way that helps all of you know the diverse readers that you have feel seen while you can still keep your stories anchored to the themes that you're trying to share as part of you know that character development and what you're trying to get across?
Speaker 1Yeah, thank you for the question and thank you for kind of you know, I really in some ways the book is very blunt in sort of laying out a certain approach or you know, and there was there's a moment in Girl Falling where Finn wants to see her girlfriend's body and she is not allowed, and it is meant to echo what happens when we take rights away from from people and dictate what kind of relationships are are kind of sacrosanct under the law and which ones aren't. Um so you know, there was there was some very definite kind of decisions made. At the same time, I'm trying to tell a cracking yarn, and I I think when when you go specific and you go into people in their fullness and and sort of trust the reader that the reader can handle that that may be not exactly their experience or what they uh what they might have thought about, but they can see the specificity of it and that it rings true for that person. And it's interesting because it is a really interesting time to be writing queer characters because I do feel like when I wrote Dirt Town, I was a lot more I I sort of felt like I had benefited from um all of the queer writers and and kind of queer activists and people that have gone before me, and I in some ways I felt I I I I was no longer constrained to just write a positive queer story. So someone like Sarah Michaels, the cop in my first book, is a queer character who you find out has done things that it are not, you know, she's sort of she's not um a beacon, it's not a coming out story, it's not sort of and I I felt really lucky to kind of not be constrained and to feel like queer characters get to have the full gamut of um get to live in the grey as well. Um but it is really interesting, yeah. It's interesting at this in this time and place and and in the context of Girl Falling, um, I still claim that right to write complex queer characters that are not that are not perfect and are not, but I I also um you know it it sort of sucks to see the ways in which rights and and things that we really thought had weren't going to go away, particularly for kind of um people in the trans community, like it's really scary actually to think that things that I just thought that wouldn't kind of come back again, even in the space of having written two books, feel a lot more sort of um pressing right now. So I, you know, I kind of hope to keep writing complex queer characters because I think I'm sort of um I enjoy it too much to stop at this point. But also um, yeah, I'm aware that, you know, I don't hold it against anybody who just wants to read Heartstopper and wants to read just like, you know, like a happy, you know, happy story. And that is not what you're getting when you open a Hayley Scrivener book. Like you are you are getting something that will make you feel and will make you um that certainly hopes to offer you characters that I have really lived with and and kind of try to show in the fullness of their humanity. Um but yeah, some sometimes my books, and I do think I love a book that really allows me to to kind of um see that whatever is going on in my own life, human beings are kind of united in the fact that we we suffer and we persevere and we find each other and we make mistakes and we you know we we sort of it's all part of the human experience and we are not alone. Um, yeah, so that's really really important to me. I don't know if that answers your question at all, but it sort of all feels like it's yeah.
Speaker 2No, I I I think it does. It's about pulling together, um I I think at the core of it it's it's wanting to tell real stories about real people in a way that is interesting for others but gives us a chance to understand and you know some different perspectives and I always think fiction is kind of truer than true, you know.
Speaker 1It's like if you want to share a fact, you know, that's one thing, but if you want to share the truth, I think um fiction is really somewhere that you can you can uh can reach people. Absolutely.
SpeakerAnd they are just such strong and genuine characters as well, uh they're complex, um and they're intriguing, so no, it's um it's and it's funny, you know, because they they they are, as we've said, two very different books, and the number of people that sidle up to me, like, oh I really preferred your second book, and then the people that sidle up and say, Oh no, I love I I really preferred your first book, and it's like great, well you'll just have to keep buying my books to see.
Speaker 1You know, I mean that's the hope. And I think one thing, you know, my my blessing and my curse is that you know, and my kind of superpower and my kryptonite is emotional kind of earnestness. Like, I am just know anything you read in my books, like I am feeling it. I'm not um I have never been able to kind of sit above and kind of be the puppet master, and when I try, my fiction is kind of dead, dead, dead. I have to feel it and I have to go there and I have to cry, and I have, you know, I sort of I've had a real thing writing my third book where I realized, oh, I've been trying to hold this book at an emotional distance, and that's just not how it works for me. And Sally Rinney has this great quote of like, whatever you think think about my books, like just know that they are sincere. Like if they are, they are they are not me trying to pull one over anyone. And I really I thought that was beautiful because I'm certainly that's certainly how I feel.
SpeakerWell, that's the end of part one of our conversation with Haley Scrivener. Be sure to join us next week for part two.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
In Competition
Sean & Jim
He Read She Read
He Read She Read
Writer's Routine
Dan Simpson
Stories Behind the Story with Better Reading
Better Reading PodcastLiterary Anything
City of Marion Libraries
Talking Aussie Books
Claudine Tinellis